When I begin the process of designing a garden, one of the most common questions from clients is “which is best: natural stone paving or porcelain paving?”. The truth is, each one has its own unique benefits – so to help you make the best choice for your outdoor space, let’s explore both materials.
The advantages of natural stone paving
Natural stone is a timeless choice for garden paving, offering a combination of elegance and character. Each stone is unique, with natural variations in texture and pattern that add charm and authenticity to a garden. Materials like sandstone, limestone, granite and slate come in a variety of finishes, making it easy to find a style that complements your design.
Natural stone paving is also incredibly hard-wearing and can withstand heavy use. Granite and slate, in particular, are known for their resilience. Being a natural material, stone is eco-friendly and blends seamlessly with the local environment. Over time, natural stone develops a weathered patina that enhances its character rather than detracting from its beauty.
The disadvantages of natural stone paving
Natural stone can be more expensive than porcelain, especially for premium materials like granite or travertine. When it comes to installation and maintenance, you need to be aware that natural stone is heavy, potentially making it more labour intensive. Softer stones like limestone, may require a sealing application to prevent staining and weather damage. They are also more prone to moss and algae buildup, which requires regular cleaning.
The advantages of porcelain paving
Porcelain paving has surged in popularity thanks to its sleek and stylish appearance, versatility and low maintenance. Perfect for modern gardens, porcelain offers a contemporary, clean finish, with consistent colours and patterns that work well in minimalist designs.
Being non-porous, porcelain paving is resistant to staining, water absorption and algae growth. Lower maintenance than stone paving, a quick sweep or wash is usually all it takes to keep slabs looking pristine.
Being incredibly strong and scratch-resistant, porcelain paving is capable of withstanding heavy foot traffic and garden furniture without suffering damage. Compared to natural stone, porcelain is lighter and easier to cut, which can reduce installation costs. It is also virtually frost-resistant, making it an excellent choice for British gardens.
The disadvantages of porcelain paving
While I love the versatility of porcelain slabs, some types look less natural so may not suit traditional or period properties. While high-quality porcelain can mimic natural stone finishes, it often lacks the depth and colour variations of genuine stone.
If you have young children or elderly relatives, please be aware that some porcelain finishes can be slippery, particularly when wet. To help mitigate this issue, opt for textured or anti-slip porcelain tiles with a minimum slip rating of R11 (the least slippery being R13).
Unlike natural stone, porcelain does not develop a patina or weathered look. Its appearance remains consistent, which may not appeal to those who prefer a rustic style. Finally, while generally cheaper than natural stone, some high-end porcelain products can be expensive.
Which should you choose?
Both natural stone paving and porcelain paving have their place in garden design. Ultimately, the final decision depends on your garden’s style, your personal preferences and your budget. If you’re unsure, please feel free to contact me for a discussion about the best option for your outdoor space.
I am a professional garden designer covering Hertfordshire and Bedfordshire, including Letchworth, Hitchin, Stevenage, Harpenden, St Albans, Bedford and the surrounding villages. I can help you weigh up the different options and create a stunning garden space tailored to your property, personal preferences and lifestyle needs. Contact me today.